top of page

Patricia J. O'Neill

Apr 1
3 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

1935 - 2026

Patricia J. O'Neill

OBITUARY

Patricia J. O'Neill

April 10, 1935 - April 1, 2026


Patricia J. O’Neill, the first married woman to head the vocation team of a Catholic religious order in the United States, died on April 1, 2026. She was 90.

The daughter of James A. and Lillian (Oldridge) McKaigney, Patricia grew up in East Rockaway, N.Y., and graduated from St. Raymond’s Elementary School there. After graduating from St. Agnes High School in Rockville Centre, she earned an English degree from St. John’s University, where she wrote for the school newspaper.

She worked as a secretary at Ted Bates, the marketing firm in Manhattan, and married Nicholas O’Neill of Oyster Bay, N.Y. in 1958. They moved to Rockville Centre, N.Y., and after leaving her job she gave birth to her son and dedicated herself to volunteer work.

She wrote and edited the monthly magazine for St. Agnes Cathedral parish in Rockville Centre for 11 years, profiling parishioners and religious.

Then she worked for a company researching and writing the histories of Long Island parishes.

At 50 she decided to further explore her faith by taking religious studies courses at Fordham University. The dean encouraged her to pursue a master’s degree in religious studies.

“I felt as though I had opened a chest of spiritual treasure,” she wrote in her master’s thesis.

“As I read the course books I saw in print what I had long suspected in my own experience,” she wrote. “God is present in the very ordinary events of life, in the smallest kindnesses. It all matters. Being unafraid to show gentleness, tenderness or compassion to those we meet in the course of a day is grace itself.”

The Rev. Robert Joerger, provincial of the East Coast Passionists, told her he had a vision to appoint a married woman to lead the Passionists’ vocation team, to help ease the fears of families as sons considered joining.

So Patricia became the first married woman to head the vocation team of a Catholic order in the U.S. And for eight years she helped guide young men to the priesthood. She later edited a vocation newsletter for the Redemptorists.

One future priest she worked with later wrote to her, “I will never forget the intricate role you held in my formation journey. I am a better person for having come to know and love you. You shall truly be rewarded one day for helping to bring so many men closer to their vocational calling.”

One Passionist wrote to her saying, “You were a pioneer. Pioneers may reach their goal, but only after scaling mountains, struggling through burning deserts, crossing uncharted waters. You did it all. You rejoiced. You suffered. We thank you.”

In addition to her parents and husband, Patricia is predeceased by her sister, Elizabeth McKaigney of East Rockaway, N.Y.

Patricia is survived by her son, James M. O’Neill and his wife, Ellen Prescott O’Neill of Essex Fells, N.J., as well as her two grandsons, Seamus O’Neill of Washington, D.C. and Liam O’Neill of Chatham, N.J., and the extended O’Neill family.

In lieu of flowers please consider making a donation in Patricia’s name to the Passionists, the Redemptorists, the De La Salle School in Freeport, N.Y. or Fordham University.


SERVICES

Visitation Thursday, April 9, 2026, 4 PM – 7 PM Macken Mortuary, Inc. - Rockville Centre, 52 Clinton Ave, Rockville Centre, 11570


Service Friday, April 10, 2026, 10:45 AM St. Agnes Cathedral, 29 Quealy Place, Rockville Centre, 11570

 
 
 

2 Comments


Cin Rich
Apr 05

Wishing your Mom and MIL, Pat, eternal rest and peace. She was a lovely and so interesting woman, and to read details Abt all she accomplished is amazing. love and hugs, to you, Ellen, James, Seamus, and Liam. May you gain comfort from all the memories and love. ❤️Cin, John, Dylan and Madeline.

Like

Krys
Apr 05

My condolences to the O’Neill Family. Take comfort that Patricia is reunited with Nicholas. I was a student at De La Salle and Nicholas was a beloved tutor at DLS. May they both rest in eternal peace.


A candle was lit for Patricia J. O'Neill.

Edited
Like

Please sign guest book below

 
Please do not visit unauthorized third party obituary sites that copy this information to sell you products and services. 
 

bottom of page